1234 ->
^^
vv
List results:
Search options:
Use \ before commas in usernames
Edit history:
arkarian: 2010-11-17 11:53:39 pm
arkarian: 2008-08-15 07:45:58 pm
red chamber dream
I've begun writing a short (?) story, and I'd like some feedback. I'll be posting the story in parts, but I won't be updating regularly, as I'm posting as I write so I can hear yall's thoughts and do some more editing. The story is currently untitled and will remain so until finished.

The first chapter is nearly completely autobiographical (but the other nine will not be). Here are the preface and first part of the first chapter:




Chapter One: Glory Fades


Preface — Francis Scott Key High

Ethan's earliest real relationship, or at least what he defined as real, occurred over the entire course of his freshmen year. She was nearly three years older than him at the time, and probably still was. Ethan didn't know; he hadn't talked to her but once since FSK, and he doubted that drunken phone call counted for very much. But he assumed there was a greater than average chance of her being dead by now if she were still as impulsive as he once knew her to be. It was that impulsiveness, that rashness that attracted Ethan in the first place: he had no choice in the matter.


Part I — Strawsburg

There were a few seats on the bus that weren't occupied, but one in particular lay beneath a girl in a white sweatshirt who immediately caught my eye. I figured there was nothing wrong with taking the most attractive option when given the choice and gladly seized the opportunity. She was facing the window and didn't shift when I sat down.

As the bus started moving, I looked over at her and realized at once that she was crying: no one sat that still with their head pressed to a cold pane of glass at that angle unless they were upset, and the silent, subtle shaking of her shoulders told me the rest.

She was beautiful: that wasn't difficult to see, even from only the back of her head, but I didn't understand why such a beautiful girl was crying, especially on the bus ride to a volleyball match. While her teammates mentally prepared for the three upcoming sets—or four or five if they played particularly poorly—here she sat with her mind on anything but volleyball, and that certainly couldn't have been healthy for the impending match. As much as I desired to, there was nothing I could do for either hers or the team's sake: my shyness generally stopped me from initiating conversation, and in this particular situation, it was probably insurmountable.

"Hey." White Sweatshirt Girl was looking at me now. She hadn't bothered to dry her eyes, which greatly pleased me. This was why females were far superior to males.

"Hey. You okay?"

"Yeah," she sighed, "I'm fine." She was finished crying. I assumed from her slightly exaggerated sigh that she wanted to tell me about this particular trouble, so I provoked her.

"What's wrong?" I chose the casual, inappropriately light tone that usually worked in situations like this.

"My best friend from Florida hates me."

"Why?"

She sighed again. "Well, his name's Brandon. His family is friends with my family, so I go down there every year with my parents and stuff. I'm like best friends with him, but he's gay, so nothing would ever happen between us. But he's really cool and I love him a lot. The problem is that I got really close to his brother Rob this year and had sex with him and Brandon just now found out."

"So he hates you now?"

"Yeah. I didn't really talk to Rob much at all before this year, so I guess he's jealous of the attention or something."

"That's a stupid reason to hate someone," I informed her. "It's not like you did anything wrong." I knew that most other people, if given my position, would disagree, but I felt nothing resembling animosity toward her— she was entirely innocent to me.

"Yeah, well, he's not talking to me either way."

"So? Don't worry about it. That's his loss."

She smiled just a bit, and I noticed how very much I liked her dark blue eyes.

"I guess so." Yes, her eyes were definitely my favorite of her features. They made her look tired, but that wasn't at all unattractive— I liked the way they wandered all about unless she was looking directly at me, and when she did, I could not turn my own away. Suddenly I felt like a very dull person.

"Aren't you a freshman?" I was glad she asked this, as I was wondering her age as well. It was the day of their first match: I hadn't seen the team in uniform yet and therefore had no way of knowing whether she was JV or varsity.

Her fleeting smile returned just as I started to answer. It made her eyes sparkle in their tired way, and for a moment I couldn't speak.

"Yep. How old are you?" That was more like it.

"Seventeen— I'm a junior."

Seventeen. It seemed not too young, but not too old, not too innocent, but not too mature, and here was this beautiful creature sitting beside me, sharing a small but significant part of her life with a freshman boy she had just met. And she was seventeen. It was my perfect age, and she was perfect.

"So you're on varsity?" We both knew it was a useless question, but I was trying to make conversation. As much as I hated small talk, especially immediately after a more personal exchange, I was willing to continue, for her sake. Besides, if small talk were ever appropriate, it was now.

"Yeah, but I won't get to play much. I'm not very good." Whether she was being earnest, modest, or self-deprecating didn't matter much to me. I just wanted to hear her voice, always cutely gentle, but always confident. In fact, I could tell that everything about her was confident, from her mannerisms to her speech, even from what little interaction we had had. She was always to the point: simple and direct.

I couldn't resist her.

"So what's your name?" I was not used to asking girls' names; I liked to wait for them to ask me. But the circumstances now were very different, and it seemed almost vital for me to ask first.

"Nicole."

Nicole wore very little makeup, if any at all. I didn't like when girls wore makeup, so it suited me wonderfully. Of course. As far as I could tell, everything about her was wonderful, and always simple. Direct.

"I'm Ethan."

There was a pause that lasted for at least half a minute. I think I was holding my breath during its entirety.

"Hey do you have AIM?" she asked, finally, in a playful, almost laughing voice. It reminded me of my own light tone, the one I had used so effectively minutes ago. I didn't know what to make of it.

"Yep." Of course I had AIM. Instant messaging was direct.

"Here, I'll give you my screenname. You can talk to me whenever you want; I'm on like all the time."

"Okay, cool."

She hastily pushed up the black sleeve of my sweatshirt and wrote the username on my forearm with the five-cent ballpoint pen she had quickly pulled from her backpack beneath our seat. If I were fortunate, the ink would last through the night, but to be safe I would have to take extreme care during the volleyball match and subsequent ride home. It would be worth the effort.

"Thanks." I gingerly rolled the sleeve back down.

"Seriously, you better IM me sometime. I don't have any freshman friends." She was using her playful tone again— I wondered if she talked like that with everyone. Still unsure what to make of it, I stared at the combination of letters and numbers inscribed onto my pale flesh instead, silently vowing not to let anything that evening rub them out.

Her handwriting could only be described as a scrawl, though I wasn't sure if she always wrote like that or if it was just because she had written on my arm. I hoped her actual handwriting was not too different from the black lettering on my forearm, as the bubbly, slanted letters intrigued appealed to me in a very surreal way. They were unlike any other girls' writing: they were uniquely Nicole. I wished she would write more, all over my arms and hands and legs and all four of the notebooks in my backpack just so I could look at all the different lines and shapes forever: I would never be bored again.

After a while, I glanced over at my seat-mate, hoping for once that she wouldn't be looking back at me— it seemed better to admire her secretly, at least for now. Nicole had resumed staring out the window, only now she wasn't crying like before. It was greatly satisfying to know I alone was the reason for that, though it still didn't seem possible that she could exist in my dull life. But each time I stole a glance to my left, Nicole was sitting there in a white sweatshirt like any ordinary person might, even though she was far more magnificent than every ordinary person.

We were quiet the rest of the ride; the many words and thoughts left unspoken were instead tacitly understood. I could feel them, and I knew she could too. At this point in our friendship—I assumed I was now permitted to call it that—that was the most satisfying knowledge yet.
Thread title: 
Devonodev: Other D
this is great

i suck at writing, so i cant really help.
i will stay tuned for more parts
One shall stand, one shall ball.
Quote from Ark:
Whether she was being earnest, modest, or earnestly self-deprecating


It's a bit nitpicky, but "earnest modest earnestly" sounds kind of strange to me. "Modest, earnest, or earnestly self-deprecating" sounds a bit better to me, though removing one use of earnest might work too.

I'll give you credit for going with first person narrative here, it does work pretty well for this part. Much better than I expected.
Quote:
It was that impulsiveness, that rashness that attracted Ethan in the first place: he had no choice in the matter.
If I am understanding this right, shouldn't this be a semicolon?

Quote:
but I didn’t understand why such a beautiful girl was crying
this bothered me a little; it's not like beautiful girls are less likely to cry than other people.

Interesting story nonetheless.  Arrow Arrow Arrow Arrow
red chamber dream
Quote from devonodev:
this is great

i suck at writing, so i cant really help.
i will stay tuned for more parts


Thanks, even feedback like that helps.


Quote from tomatobob:
It's a bit nitpicky, but "earnest modest earnestly" sounds kind of strange to me. "Modest, earnest, or earnestly self-deprecating" sounds a bit better to me, though removing one use of earnest might work too.


Yeah, I agree that sentence is pretty awkward. I was trying to be clever, but I guess it just isn't very good. I'll work on it and get back to you.

Quote from tomatobob:
I'll give you credit for going with first person narrative here, it does work pretty well for this part. Much better than I expected.


Thanks. Everyone: I was originally writing this in third person, but then I realized there was no need for it to be. I didn't want to write any narrative that wasn't running through Ethan's/my head, so I figured first person would be the more interesting choice. I'd never written in first person before, so this should be good practice for it.


Quote from Bolognab:
Quote from Arkarian:
It was that impulsiveness, that rashness that attracted Ethan in the first place: he had no choice in the matter.

If I am understanding this right, shouldn't this be a semicolon?


It could be, but I felt a colon was more appropriate. Colons are generally used when the second sentence clarifies or expounds on the first. They also mark a slightly longer pause, which I wanted there.

Quote from Bolognab:
this bothered me a little; it's not like beautiful girls are less likely to cry than other people.


It was sort of meant to bother people, so if it did, then it means it's doing its job. Remember, this is a first person narrative of what was going through my head at the time. Blinded by her presence, that's precisely what I thought. All that said, it's a pretty corny sentence and should probably be rewritten. Glad you liked the rest, though.
One shall stand, one shall ball.
Quote from Arkarian:
All that said, it's a pretty corny sentence and should probably be rewritten.


I don't know, given the situation in this part, the corny-ness seems appropriate. It sounds like a bad pick up line, the kind of thing a high school freshman would think up in an attempt to seem cool and impress some chick only to realize just in time that it sucks..
Edit history:
arkarian: 2008-08-09 01:49:55 pm
red chamber dream
Heh, good thing I didn't say it aloud. That stuff comes later. ;)
Edit history:
arkarian: 2008-08-15 07:51:06 pm
red chamber dream
Part II — Rally Scoring

The Eagles won their match. They always did. FSK volleyball was among the best in the state, and I was proud to be a part of it. Though in the 'grand scheme of things' I was fairly insignificant, I still felt integral to the team. I didn't play volleyball, of course—the school had no boys' team, and I doubt I would have tried out if it had—instead I did the next best thing.


My friend Jake's sister, Naomi, was on varsity this year, and during the many lazy summer days at their house, he joked with her about him and me taking the Volleyball Manager positions, just to annoy her. I had never entertained the idea all that seriously, and by the time winter rolled around, I had forgotten it completely— until one cold afternoon Jake stopped me out of the blue in the school's rear parking lot as I was walking to Bus 38.

We were going to be Volleyball Managers, and we started today.

Neither Jake nor I had cell phones, so I scrambled to find some quarters. My brother would get home soon after the bus, but he'd likely leave again after getting something to eat. I was going to miss the bus, and if my mom wasn't going to be home that evening I might be sunk: I had left my house keys on the living room divider.

There was a pay phone outside the school's main entrance, and another in the lobby. I chose the lobby's and was relieved to hear my mom's voice on the other end.


Being a Volleyball Manager wasn't going to be difficult. Coach Rau quickly taught Jake and me how to keep the score book (write down who earns which points) and play book (one of us calls out each dig, set, block, kill, and fault; the other writes them down), and during home games one of us had to run the clock. I had tons of practice with the clock: I had run it for basketball games a lot as a little kid, and in volleyball you didn't even have to keep the time, just the points. So the clock keeper was the coveted position of particularly lazy–feeling Volleyball Managers.

As it turned out, there was a third Manager, Steve, the half-brother of one of the girls on the team. He seemed pretty nice, so alongside him and Jake, I knew from that first afternoon that I'd enjoy the job. I figured we'd get to hang out with all the attractive girls on the team after school twice a week, then watch them getting physical in tight spandex shorts. I never once expected my favorite part to be the bus rides.


The Eagles won their match. We won our match. Admittedly, the Century Knights were a fairly poor team, but it still felt good to have absolutely annihilated them: 6–25, 5–25, 3–25. I loved hearing the various synchronous stomps and cheers the girls did each time one of them got an ace—an unreturned, untouched in–bounds serve:

Stomp stomp stomp stomp clap stomp clap clap "ahhhhh, ace!"

Stomp stomp clap, stomp, stomp clap, "A–C–E!"


and my favorite:

Stomp. Stomp. Stomp stomp stomp "ACE!"


Jake and I tallied quite a few that night.

Nicole only played for a few minutes, but I thought she did rather well for a second–string Outside Hitter, very graceful on the court, despite being a lot taller than most of the other girls. I counted very few faults in her column of the play book.

Unfortunately, we never once spoke at Century, even during the ten–minute breaks between sets. I would hang around the players' bench with Jake and talk to Naomi or one of the other girls I knew from elsewhere, but Nicole never even glanced at me when she came near. My parents were coming to pick me up that night, presumably to hear all about being a Volleyball Manager, so I wasn't going to be able to talk to Nicole on the bus ride home. Those short breaks were the perfect chance, really the only opportunity to hear her playfully casual voice again, but she seemed completely disinterested.

Had we not just had a pivotal conversation on the bus? I realized that was entirely possible— what if I had imagined the entire thing? More likely was that the exchange hadn't gone how I remembered. Maybe we had just said hi, followed by more of her incomprehensible crying. I knew how much I liked to idealize people and situations, often to the point of fantasy, so it certainly seemed plausible, but I was always aware of my idealizing.

Wasn't I?

Then it hit me: I could be certain.

I slowly rolled up the sleeve of my sweatshirt.
You had some funky varying spaces between paragraphs this chapter. Sometimes you had one line between paragraphs and sometimes you had two. I am assuming this was for a time/idea transition.

Quote:
The Eagles won their match.
Quote:
The Eagles won their match.
You said the same thing twice...in the intro and in the 8th? paragraphlet (let because I don't know what to call those one sentence paragraphs).

Again, pretty interesting read. I'm wondering what stunt you're about to pull at the end right now.
red chamber dream
Quote from Bolognab:
You had some funky varying spaces between paragraphs this chapter. Sometimes you had one line between paragraphs and sometimes you had two. I am assuming this was for a time/idea transition.


Yeah, that's exactly what it is. Since on the forum the lines are much longer than in a word processor, the larger breaks look weirder, but if you were reading it as a document, it'd look much better.


Quote from Bolognab:
Quote:
The Eagles won their match.
Quote:
The Eagles won their match.

You said the same thing twice...in the intro and in the 8th? paragraphlet


That was intentional. It's to show that I'm returning to the exact time I started Part II with.


Quote from Bolognab:
Again, pretty interesting read. I'm wondering what stunt you're about to pull at the end right now.


No stunt coming up immediately, just another time jump— I don't plan on starting any of the parts at the precise time the previous part ended, but I'm pretty sure I won't ever jump backward in time again.

As for any stunts at the end, you'll just have to wait and see about those. :P
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Unfortunately, I don't have much time right now, but I can at least let my critical nature shine through and point out some errors I noticed in chapter one...
Quote from Arkarian:
Suddenly, I felt like a very dull person.



"Hey, do you have AIM?"



I wished she would write more, all over my arms and hands and legs and all four of the notebooks in my backpack just so I could look at all the different lines and shapes forever: I would never be bored again.
I think the highlighted colon would be better as a semicolon, or perhaps just reworded.
red chamber dream
I did want it to seem like a run–on sentence, but I agree about the colon not really working. I'm thinking either a period or em dash— it's just I use those too damn much when writing in first person, so I was trying to change it up a bit.
Edit history:
BioSpark: 2008-08-10 11:49:49 pm
Good job so far.

Quote:
She hadn’t bothered to dry her eyes, which greatly pleased me. This was why females were far superior to males.

Haha. Yeah.

Quote:
"So? Don’t worry about it. That’s his loss."

You're always the relationship expert, ark!

Quote:
I liked the way they sort of wandered all about unless she was looking directly at me

imo "sort of" is a weak thing to say. I know you meant they don't exactly wander or literally wander, but I wouldn't know anything better to do than to take it out.

Quote:
Seventeen. It seemed not too young, but not too old, not too innocent, but not too mature, and here was this beautiful creature sitting beside me, sharing a small but significant part of her life with a freshman boy she had just met. And she was seventeen. It was my perfect age, and she was perfect.

Sounds just like me, except for the being female part. :o

Quote:
Nicole wore very little makeup, if any at all. I didn’t like when girls wore makeup, so it suited me wonderfully. Of course. As far as I could tell, everything about her was wonderful, and always simple. Direct.

I agree.

Quote:
If I were fortunate, the ink would last through the night, but to be safe I would have to take extreme care during the volleyball match and subsequent ride home. It would be worth the effort.

Dude, just write it down somewhere else or memorize it.

Quote:
the school had no boys’ team

Wow. Ours always has. The only sport that has no boys' team is badminton (I wish there was; it's the only sport I'm good at).

I forgot everything else.
red chamber dream
Quote from BioSpark:
imo "sort of" is a weak thing to say. I know you meant they don't exactly wander or literally wander, but I wouldn't know anything better to do than to take it out.


I guess I used it because it's so hard to describe how her eyes moved, but yeah, it is a pretty weak phrase. Removed.


Quote from BioSpark:
Dude, just write it down somewhere else or memorize it.


Heh, you can see how strangely she made my brain work. ;)


Quote from BioSpark:
The only sport that has no boys' team is badminton (I wish there was; it's the only sport I'm good at).


Same here. <3 badminton.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I just got around to reading part 2, and in this, I noticed only one error:
Quote from Arkarian:
I had ran it for basketball games a lot as a little kid
I like this story, even though it's not really a genre I tend to enjoy. And one that I can't really relate to. >_>
What's the mistake ?
Edit history:
arkarian: 2008-08-11 11:43:13 am
red chamber dream
He highlighted it. I forgot an 'a' before 'little'. Also, 'run', not 'ran' is the past participle of 'run'.

Thanks for catching that, uNsane. I'm glad you're enjoying the story so far.
Edit history:
arkarian: 2008-08-13 06:45:21 pm
red chamber dream
Part III — Tennis

theoffspring01: hey
xfarfromp3rfectx: hey whos this?
       
I laughed aloud at her username, wondering if she had meant to be so ironic with it. Irony or not, it was much better than my lame handle.

theoffspring01: ethan
theoffspring01: from the volleyball bus

No response for what seemed like a while. I held my breath— did she really not want to talk to me?

xfarfromp3rfectx: oh hey!!
xfarfromp3rfectx: how are you?

I breathed out slowly, relieved.

theoffspring01: pretty good
theoffspring01: you played well tonight
xfarfromp3rfectx: i barely played at all.. but thanks lol
theoffspring01: did you know you got the least faults out of everyone?
xfarfromp3rfectx: no wayyy
theoffspring01: yeah lol

Another pause. This was common on Instant Messenger, so I wasn't too worried. At least now I knew she would talk to me. I imagined how her voice might pronounce the words she typed. Her "no wayyy" in particular sounded very Nicole–like to me.

xfarfromp3rfectx: so it was good talking to you on the bus tonight
theoffspring01: yeah.. you still doing ok?
xfarfromp3rfectx: yeah, since i talked to you
theoffspring01: i'm glad :)
xfarfromp3rfectx: are you going to be at practice tomorrow?
theoffspring01: nah i only stay after on game days
xfarfromp3rfectx: oh :(

Her frowny face appeared on my screen as a 'sad' emoticon—I had disabled emoticons in my own messages out of my loathing for them—but made me smile nonetheless. More irony.

theoffspring01: but i'll be there thursday, so don't worry :P

I hoped Thursday's was another away game. Nicole's response came quickly, as if answering my silent question.

xfarfromp3rfectx: will you sit next to me on the bus again?

I attempted to casually conceal my excitement. It was easy to do on AIM, as I'd had years of practice.

theoffspring01: if you want me to
xfarfromp3rfectx: duh

Unable to hit the ball back, I quickly went to grab a glass of milk from the kitchen after a few seconds of hesitation. When I returned, still nothing. As much as I despised small talk, sometimes it was necessary.

theoffspring01: where's the game at thursday?
xfarfromp3rfectx: liberty... i think

Liberty's volleyball team had been number one in the county, and often the state, for years. FSK's was excellent of course, but I doubted we stood much chance against them.

theoffspring01: they any good?
xfarfromp3rfectx: theyve always been like the best in the county.. so it probably wont be a very fun game lol

She didn't seem to be wildly delusional about sports like so many other athletes were. I definitely wasn't the sports enthusiast either, so it was refreshing to know the target of my affection was similar to me, at least in that regard.

theoffspring01: well that's ok i guess

Lame reply, but all I had for tonight. I debated giving her a subtle hint of how much she meant to me, even after knowing her for just one day, but once again she beat me to the punch, as if she could read my mind.

xfarfromp3rfectx: well i have to go, it's getting late
xfarfromp3rfectx: cant wait for the bus ride!
theoffspring01: me neither!
xfarfromp3rfectx: hehe.. you can be my pet freshman ;)
xfarfromp3rfectx: bye
theoffspring01: night
(23:02) AIM System Alert: xfarfromp3rfectx has gone offline.

I stared at the smudged CRT screen.

"Pet freshman", what could that mean— some sort of 'thing' upper classmen had with certain ninth graders, like a sort of mentorship? Did a lot of juniors do this? Was it something sanctioned by the school, or had Nicole just invented the term, teasing me because she… liked me? Whatever it symbolized, I was enthralled by the idea of being something of hers.

It was far past my ten o'clock bedtime; I switched the computer off without shutting down, then slowly crept to bed, my thoughts racing.

Hers.
Looks really good so far, better than anything I've written anyway.  Arrow Arrow Arrow Arrow
Quote from BioSpark:
Quote:
Nicole wore very little makeup, if any at all. I didn’t like when girls wore makeup, so it suited me wonderfully. Of course. As far as I could tell, everything about her was wonderful, and always simple. Direct.

I agree.




Quote:
"Pet freshman": what could that mean


I think ellipses would do the job better than a colon.  But that's just me.
red chamber dream
Quote from Gamma_Metroid:
Looks really good so far, better than anything I've written anyway.  Arrow Arrow Arrow Arrow


Thanks so much.


Quote from Gamma_Metroid:
Quote:
"Pet freshman": what could that mean


I think ellipses would do the job better than a colon.  But that's just me.


I try to minimize the use of ellipses as much as possible— they're weak writing imo. You'll see I used one (the first one of the story, in fact!) later in that paragraph, and I'd really rather not have another one right there.

I do agree that the colon isn't really best. I experimented with using a line break, but maybe just a period would be best.
One shall stand, one shall ball.
Quote from Arkarian:
"Pet freshman": what could that mean, some sort of 'thing' upper classmen had with certain ninth graders, like a sort of mentorship?


You know I almost think it would be better to rework the sentence in to two.

"'Pet freshman', what could that mean, some sort of 'thing' upperclassmen had with certain ninth graders? Like a sort of mentorship?"

Or:

"'Pet freshman', what could that mean? Some sort of 'thing' upperclassmen had with certain ninth graders, like a sort of mentorship?"

Of course a line break might end up working better overall, it would establish the pause that you seem to be looking for there a bit better than a colon, I think.

I really enjoyed this part though, good work Arky.
red chamber dream
Glad you liked Part III, and thanks for the crit! I'm going with your second suggestion, but what do you think of using a dash instead of the first question mark?

"'Pet freshman', what could that mean— some sort of 'thing' upperclassmen had with certain ninth graders, like a sort of mentorship?"

I really want that hesitation between "mean" and "some", but too many question marks clutter up the flow a bit too much, and I don't want the... 'questionness' there. I dunno, it's hard to explain what I mean.
One shall stand, one shall ball.
I see what you're saying, and yeah, the dash would be good. I didn't suggest it since you mentioned earlier that you felt you used them too much, I figured I'd suggest something different.
Whenever Nicole is mentioned, I think of that girl in your avatar. >_>
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Quote from Arkarian:
        "Pet freshman", what could that mean— some sort of 'thing' upper classmen had with certain ninth graders, like a sort of mentorship?
I, personally, feel that the best thing there would be question marks, rather than a comma or colon and a dash.

"Pet freshman"? What could that mean?