Username:
B
I
U
S
"
url
img
#
code
sup
sub
font
size
color
smiley
Not talking
Brick wall
Very Happy
Shhh
Confused
Applause
Boo hoo!
Dancing
Shame on you
Whistle
extra_smug
aiwebs_008
aiwebs_016
aiwebs_032
aiwebs_031
aiwebs_030
aiwebs_029
aiwebs_028
aiwebs_027
aiwebs_026
aiwebs_025
aiwebs_024
aiwebs_023
aiwebs_022
aiwebs_021
aiwebs_020
aiwebs_019
aiwebs_018
aiwebs_017
aiwebs_015
aiwebs_014
aiwebs_013
aiwebs_012
aiwebs_011
aiwebs_010
aiwebs_009
aiwebs_007
aiwebs_006
aiwebs_005
aiwebs_004
aiwebs_003
aiwebs_002
aiwebs_001
aiwebs_000
Angel
Drool
Speak to the hand
Liar
Pray
Sick
Silenced
d'oh!
Eh?
Liar
grin new
Twisted Evil
Neutral
Mr. Green
Anxious
Think
cookie
laugh new
Shocked
Arrow
Smile
winky
stern
teach
Evil or Very Mad
Wink
Embarassed
Rolling Eyes
Very Happy
Cool
Razz
Idea
keks
whoa (@c.bags)
pwuh
Sad
Surprised
Confused
Laughing
Mad
Crying or Very sad
wub
gah
Exclamation
Question
page  12345678910111213141516 -> 1 ... 16 ->
^^
vv
List results:
Search options:
Use \ before commas in usernames
Odyssey:
registered on 2007-06-22 05:49:57 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Tallon IV
Edit history:
Odyssey: 2010-09-01 01:46:51 am
Odyssey: 2010-09-01 01:45:14 am
info 
''
"This is the first joint operation I've been a part of since I became a freelance bounty hunter. It's also the first time I've taken orders from a commanding officer since leaving the Federation army." -- Samus Aran

Whether Nintendo knew it or not, those two sentences completely invalidate the events of Metroid Prime 3: Corruption. Samus took orders from Admiral Dane, and she worked directly with the Federation army to secure the Pirate Homeworld and destroy Phaaze. If that doesn't qualify as a joint operation spearheaded by a commanding officer, I don't know what does.

The next point will reveal a boss encounter. If you haven't already played Metroid: Other M, do not un-hide it.

On top of this, she's completely paralyzed at seeing Ridley again. Assuming that Corruption didn't happen, which the dialogue suggests, she's still killed Ridley three times. While Ridley is indeed responsible for killing Samus' parents, you would think she'd be used to seeing him brought back to life by now. Metroid Prime states that Ridley died during his first fight with Samus on Zebes, necessitating his reanimation.

Let's assume Prime never happened. This means that the jury is out on whether or not Ridley actually died during the first fight on Zebes, so Samus has only definitively killed Ridley once. This makes her shock at seeing him in the magma eruption chamber much more plausible. Other than Samus' reaction, there's no solid evidence to back this up, but given Corruption's blatant erasure complimenting the theory, one can logically assume that Prime and therefore Echoes have been removed from canon as well.


Nintendo hasn't officially said anything, so this is all conjecture, but it seems to be the case.

Thoughts?
Thread title: 
ajbolt89:
registered on 2003-11-25 11:35:00 pm.
 
Location: MoonVault, The Moon
lol no way
I guess I thought what it was that she had done to make Adam mad at her, and to make her want to quit his command... well I just started the pyrosphere so what do I know, but my impression so far is that she quit his command because her maternal feelings for the baby metroid wouldn't allow her to kill it; she didn't follow orders, and she gave it to researchers instead (and adam's personal preference not to use any living thing for any purpose obviously doesn't approve of this). So she wasn't freelance, just a hired bounty hunter - part of the army but clearly a special operative, until up to the beginning of SM. Or something? This doesn't reconcile the Ridley stuff, just attempts at the Corruption stuff...


I'm probably totally wrong so I don't know. I should probably finish Other M before making guesses ha.
Boris:
registered on 2009-03-02 11:03:21 am.
 
The Overlord of All Acorns.
regardless of the situation, it doesn't make sense for samus to be paralyzed in fear by ridley.

iirc, ridley has been killed:

1. manga
2. metroid
(3). prime
(4). prime 3
(5). prime 3
3 (6). super

ridley has been seen (at least)

(1) manga
(2) manga
1. (3) metroid
(4) mecha ridley/zero mission (yes, i know this isnt ridley himself, but it still warrants inclusion)
(5) prime (beginning)
(6) prime (phendrana)
(7) prime (impact crater)
(8) prime 3 (beginning)
(9) prime 3 (seed)
2 (10) Super (beginning)
3 (11) Super (norfair)
4 (12) Other M

regardless of the situation, it isn't near the first time she has seen ridley, nor fought him.


tl;dr  They fucked up, but won't admit it.
arkarian:
is in the group Administrator.
registered on 2004-09-01 04:15:32 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: ellicott city, md, usa
Edit history:
arkarian: 2010-09-01 03:21:26 am
info 
''
mindfulness
fully erect
seems more likely that they just didn't care about making it fit in with the other games, especially the ones made in the us. that's a typically japanese way of doing things afaict.
UchihaSasuke:
registered on 2005-12-11 10:47:04 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Panama
Edit history:
UchihaSasuke: 2010-09-01 03:34:39 am
UchihaSasuke: 2010-09-01 03:33:44 am
info 
mail
''
my umbrella goes directly to Bankai
it's not like they needed to remove the prime series since it didn't break the timeline so far.
i actually missed that part of the text. i interpreted that this was her first mission under Adam's command after she quit the federation, making the mp3 events still plausible.
now, the Ridley thing is broken even if you discount the trilogy. ZM and Super happened and she kicked his ass. i guess the guys in charge of that cutscene were too far into work when they realized it wouldn't fit or maybe Sakamoto wanted that part of the backstory in 3D even if it meant breaking the timeline.
or it could be that since Adam had Samus so heart-shaken, she gave in to her fear easily, while in the other games, the isolation made her supress the fear and beat him with no objections.
PizzaBoy:
registered on 2010-06-18 06:29:43 pm.
 
The Metroid timeline is slowing following the Zelda timeline until it becomes such a mess that no one can decipher it.
kesvalk:
registered on 2009-06-04 06:24:40 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: in your mind
Indie Lover
agreed pizzaboy
May I remind you all that Team Ninja has a history of doing such things; they did it to their own games, the Ninja Gaiden series, when they 'remastered' the original games.
UnborN_Pho3nix:
registered on 2010-08-31 08:12:48 am.
 
Ahhh okay. Now I know why they stopped selling Metroid Prime Trilogy.
UchihaSasuke:
registered on 2005-12-11 10:47:04 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Panama
my umbrella goes directly to Bankai
it had more to do with bad sales.
arkarian:
is in the group Administrator.
registered on 2004-09-01 04:15:32 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: ellicott city, md, usa
mindfulness
fully erect
it was always supposed to be a limited edition thing iirc.
UchihaSasuke:
registered on 2005-12-11 10:47:04 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Panama
my umbrella goes directly to Bankai
that's true, but i'm pretty sure they would have kept selling the trilogy if it had good sales, just on a normal box instead.
and Europe didn't even get that limited edition box so there was not a reason for it to be limited there.
Toozin:
is in the group Administrator.
registered on 2003-09-14 08:25:09 pm.
 
Location: Above
Irken Elite
Why am I so amazing?
Samus being paralyzed by fear from Ridley pissed me off so badly, you have no idea.
sabata2:
registered on 2009-10-20 11:54:19 am.
 
ANKOKU
Quote from Toozin:
Samus being paralyzed by fear from Ridley pissed me off so badly, you have no idea.

well...
She DID just come back from completely annihilating him in Super. It'd be like knowing you've got WWII won (and Hitler dead), and then seeing Hitler again a month later.
Turtle:
registered on 2010-07-16 09:49:11 am.
 
Gender: male
Location: US
I like turtles.
Except
in your analogy, a sensible person wouldn't be paralyzed by fear of Hitler, they'd just shoot him again.


For what it's worth, the cutscene in question seems to be the worst moment in the game and I'm glad I know that it's coming so I won't be completely slammed into the wall by how stupid it is when I'm actually playing the game.
sabata2:
registered on 2009-10-20 11:54:19 am.
 
ANKOKU
Then
Think about if from an internment camp prisoner who, at the end of the war, rebelled against the guards and won.

They play up Ridley's "scare factor" for her childhood, which is rather stupid since she's fought and killed him like 12 times by then. But it's supposed to be an event that makes her go "oh fuckfuckfuckfuckfuck YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE DEAD!"
Toozin:
is in the group Administrator.
registered on 2003-09-14 08:25:09 pm.
 
Location: Above
Irken Elite
Why am I so amazing?
Which is, of course, contrary to Samus's behavior as established by every single other game in the series.

And don't try to tell me that because she didn't speak, she didn't have a personality. If you tell me that you are wrong.
sabata2:
registered on 2009-10-20 11:54:19 am.
 
Edit history:
sabata2: 2010-09-02 08:22:44 pm
sabata2: 2010-09-02 08:22:06 pm
info 
''
ANKOKU
Quote from sabata2:
They play up Ridley's "scare factor" for her childhood, which is rather stupid since she's fought and killed him like 12 times by then. But it's supposed to be an event that makes her go "oh fuckfuckfuckfuckfuck YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE DEAD!"


Not saying it wasn't stupid. But that's the way it's to be taken.
kesvalk:
registered on 2009-06-04 06:24:40 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: in your mind
Indie Lover
it's pretty stupid anyway, even if you take the prime games out
but as someone posted in the IGN MHtri review, no one keep his/her cool when a gigantic dragon comes charging in your direction

UchihaSasuke:
registered on 2005-12-11 10:47:04 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Panama
Edit history:
Toozin: 2010-09-03 01:01:24 am
UchihaSasuke: 2010-09-02 10:01:26 pm
info 
mail
''
my umbrella goes directly to Bankai
it is remarkable that she snapped out of it and then kicked his ass. from the reaction, you'd think she would just sit there and cry while Ridley eats her.
Toozin:
is in the group Administrator.
registered on 2003-09-14 08:25:09 pm.
 
Location: Above
Irken Elite
Why am I so amazing?
Tag your spoilers. Boss names are spoilers.
kesvalk:
registered on 2009-06-04 06:24:40 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: in your mind
Edit history:
kesvalk: 2010-09-03 10:20:17 am
kesvalk: 2010-09-03 10:20:09 am
info 
mail
''
Indie Lover
i just find it strange, that she panic at the sight of ridley, but don't at the sight of the queen metroid -_-
sabata2:
registered on 2009-10-20 11:54:19 am.
 
ANKOKU
Quote from kesvalk:
i just find it strange, that she panic at the sight of ridley, but don't at the sight of the queen metroid -_-

Queeny didn't kill her parents when she was like 8, nor did it constantly fight her every step of the way.
Prime Hunter:
registered on 2004-08-09 06:04:32 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: USA
Samus was only 3 when K2-L was attacked, which would probably be worse than if she were older. (Not that seeing Ridley kill her mother at any age wouldn't emotionally scar her to some degree.)

And even if Samus didn't react much when she saw the Queen, I know I did once I put two and two together: "Metroid eggs... what can create... uh oh."
UchihaSasuke:
registered on 2005-12-11 10:47:04 pm.
 
Gender: male
Location: Panama
my umbrella goes directly to Bankai
also, the queen is easy to kill compared to ridley so i'd bet, from Samus' POV, ridley is more scary.